(Haida Gwaii Observer/File photo)

Appeals court upholds existing two-stage plan for Haida title case

Judges dismiss a Haida Nation appeal to keep phase one focused on a broad declaration of rights

The Haida Nation has lost an appeal about how the Haida title case will go to trial.

Given how complicated it is, the Haida, B.C., and Canadian governments all agreed it would save time and money to hear the case in two phases.

The hope is that if phase one goes well, the parties can settle without phase two, or can at least keep it short.

But the parties disagreed on what each phase would deal with.

Writing last Tuesday as part of a three-judge panel with the B.C. Court of Appeal, Justice John Hunter said that first of all, higher courts can only overrule the way a trial court judge chooses to hear a case if there is a serious injustice or error in principle.

“For the reasons given in this judgement, I am of the view that no error of law or principle has been established to warrant interference by this Court,” he said.

Haida Nation v. British Columbia (Attorney General), 2018 BCCA 462 by Haida Gwaii Observer on Scribd

In its appeal, the Haida Nation argued that the way the trial judge organized the case would lead to a return of the so-called “small spots” or “postage-stamp” approach to Aboriginal rights.

That is an approach where courts only consider specific Aboriginal rights to specific parts of a territory, which has the effect of freezing the rights in time and narrowing them to particular areas.

But Justice Hunter and the other Court of Appeal judges said that is not the trial judge’s intention.

Related: Haida title case to be heard in two phases

Although the case will deal with some specific issues in phase one — alleged damages to five marine species, one forest area, and seven properties over which the Haida Nation claims title — they said the idea is not to take a “postage stamp” approach, but to look closely at a few examples of alleged damages so any remedies can be scaled-up to account for the whole of Haida Gwaii.

The Court of Appeal judges also found that in the context of a lawsuit such as the Haida title case, courts can’t declare Aboriginal rights in the broad, abstract way the Haida Nation was seeking to do in phase one, without also considering possible justifications that the B.C. or Canadian governments may have had for infringing those rights.

Although Section 35 of Canada’s 1982 Constitution Act includes protections for Aboriginal title and rights, it does not strictly define them. They are instead defined on a case-by-case basis.

On that point, Justice Hunter followed the trial judge in quoting an earlier court decision where the Cheslatta Carrier First Nation sought a court declaration that it has an existing Aboriginal right to carry out Cheslatta fisheries.

“It is clear that any aboriginal ‘right to fish’ that might be subject of a declaration would not be absolute,” wrote the judge in Cheslatta.

“Like other rights, such a right may be subject to infringement or restriction by government where such infringement is justified.”

“The point is that the definition of the circumstances in which infringement is justified is an important part of defining the right itself.”

While the provincial government sought to uphold the existing organization for the case, the federal government did not take a position on the issue.



andrew.hudson@haidagwaiiobserver.com

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Better COVID-19 testing results needed in the north

Former senior Northern Health official also wants work camps shut down

Northern Health preparing ‘for a changing situation’ in response to COVID-19

The health authority is taking a number of measures to free up hospital capacity where possible

COVID-19: Coast Mountain College cancels, postpones programs on Haida Gwaii

General interest and workforce training courses cancelled, field school postponed

UPDATE: Mother of missing Indigenous woman pleads for her safe return

23-year-old Shaylanna Lewis, who also uses the surname Brown, was last seen on March 21

UPDATE: Non-emergency ePACT alert provides information about COVID-19 response

Haida Gwaii communities sent out the alert on March 27

B.C. is seeing the highest rate of COVID-19 recovery in Canada, and there’s a few reasons why

British Columbia was one of the first to see rise in COVID-19 cases, and has also switched up testing

Sewers stitch masks to free up supplies for front-line health-care workers

“We have little old ladies sewing up a storm,” said Joan Davis

Experts weigh in on best handling of groceries during COVID-19 pandemic

Study suggests the virus can live for up to 24 hours on cardboard and up to three days on plastic

COVID-19 world update: Enforceable quarantine in NYC?; France orders 1 billion masks

Spain warns EU’s future at stake; New York governor calls Trump’s idea ‘federal declaration of war

‘Community is amazing’: Williams Lake woman organizes drive-by birthdays

With self-isolation the norm due to COVID-19 children are missing out

Earth Hour 2020 kicks off online Saturday night

Action moves online due to COVID-19

B.C. COVID-19 cases rise 92 to 884, one more death, 81 in care

Outbreak action underway in 12 long-term care homes

B.C. veterinarians want to smooth the fur of COVID-19-worried pet owners

Vets expect to continue giving your fur buddies the help they need while social distancing

B.C. VIEWS: Small businesses need our help

Just as integral in neighbourhoods in Vancouver and Surrey as they are in Prince George or Kelowna

Most Read