Citizens’ Assembly: An Experiment in Democracy

  • Apr. 20, 2009 4:00 p.m.

Article written by Nick Loenen and submitted by Karen McMurray–In 2004, the BC legislature with all-party consent unanimously created a Citizens’ Assembly consisting of one woman and one man from each constituency to recommend to British Columbians whether to keep our voting system, or accept a new way of electing MLAs. The assembly on electoral reform consisted of 160 randomly selected voters. It had no political agenda, represented every part of the province, was gender balanced, committed a year to study and deliberation, listened to 383 presentations at 50 public hearings, and consulted 1,600 on-line submissions. It was deliberative democracy at its best. Voting systems are always imposed by politicians. BC did it differently. Our assembly members, free of political influence had only one objective: What system serves the interest of voters? The assembly members are our neighbours, they understand. They discussed all the frustrations people feel at election time. And they acted. With near unanimity they recommend we change to BC-STV. It is their system of choice. In the 2005 referendum, almost 58 percent of British Columbians accepted the assembly’s recommendation. It was an impressive majority; not enough to make it law, but too close to ignore. Now, we get to do it again, on 12 May. It requires 60 percent to pass into law.After listening to British Columbians, the assembly decided on three values a voting system fit for our province should embody. Fair results- In the 2001 election, every 11,907 Liberal voters were rewarded with one seat, but it took 171,578 NDP voters to get one seat, and the nearly 200,000 Green voters got no seat. Such results are unfair to voters. Effective local representation-While MLAs can be counted on to lobby for their communities and help individuals deal with the bureaucracy, local representatives have no legislative role. On important public policy issues whether it is the carbon tax, fish farming, or privatizing BC Rail, local MLAs are largely captive to the party bosses.More choice-Have you ever voted for a party you did not like, to stop a party you liked even less, or found that the best candidate was with a party that wouldn’t have a chance of winning in your riding, or you supported a party and leader but not their local candidate? It need not be thus. In 2005, a high school class in Smithers choose pizza toppings by using first the current system and then BC-STV. Using the current system, 36 percent ended up with pizzas that were not among their top three choices. With BC-STV, only 2 of the 74 students didn’t get one of their top three choices. It’s a telling example that we can do better. The assembly listened and then guided by the three basic values: Fair Results, Effective Local Representation, and More Choice, concluded British Columbians deserve better. They recommended the single transferable vote, one of the oldest voting systems in the world, tweaked it to suit our situation, and called it BC-STV. How BC-STV works and why it holds promise to meet the assembly’s three values is the subject of following columns. Nick Loenen is a former Richmond City Councillor and MLA. For more visit: or contact:

Just Posted

Painting her way home

Janine Gibbons talks about all she learned illustrating Haida and Tlingit story books

Haida Gwaii gets top spot in The World

It was already a nice Christmas present, but Keith Moore was really… Continue reading

McNeill fined again for illegal fishing

A local man with a long history of poaching has been convicted… Continue reading

Old Massett taps grassroots for community plan

Over coffee, kitchen tables, and community dinners, Old Massett is taking a… Continue reading

Subsea internet cable to link up Haida Gwaii

Cable to connect Haida Gwaii, Prince Rupert, Vancouver Island, Sunshine Coast with mainland network

Testing the Google Arts & Culture app

Going face to face with art

VIDEO: Fuel truck and train collide in B.C. causing massive fire

More emergency crews are still arriving on scene of a massive fire at the Port Coquitlam rail yard.

Back to work: U.S. government shutdown ends after Democrats relent

Short-term spending measure means both sides could see another shutdown stalemate in three weeks

Man lives despite malfunctioning defibrillator at B.C. arena

A middle-aged man went into cardiac arrest after at game at Pitt Meadows Arena last Wednesday.

Cause of Northern B.C. seaplane crash released

TSB releases report on seaplane crash during a water landing in 2016 near First Nations community

Vancouver police crack down on pop-up pot vendors

Officers raided merchants’ tables on Robson Square late Sunday

Bell Media, NFL take appeal over Super Bowl ad rules to top court

At issue is a ban on substituting American ads with Canadian ones during the game’s broadcast

Crown seeks 4.5 years jail for B.C. woman convicted of counselling tax evasion

Debbie Anderson the latest from group to face jail for teaching debunked ‘natural person’ theory

UPDATE: Brother of B.C. teen killed by stray bullet says the death left a void

Alfred Wong, 15, was gunned down in Vancouver while on his way home from dinner with his family

Most Read