Court overturns Northern Gateway approval

A federal court overturned the 2014 approval of Northern Gateway because Ottawa failed to consult the Haida and other First Nations.

The Haida Nation and seven other First Nations won a key court ruling last week that overturned approval of Enbridge’s Northern Gateway project.

“It’s a great day for Haida Gwaii and the coast of B.C.,” said Peter Lantin (kil tlaats ‘gaa), president of the Council of the Haida Nation, in a press release.

“We’re all celebrating a victory for the oceans and our way of life.”

In a majority 2-1 ruling, judges on the Federal Court of Appeal found the Conservative government failed to properly consult the affected First Nations before granting conditional approval for the 1,117 km crude oil pipeline and Kitimat export terminal in 2014.

“Meaningful consultation is not intended simply to allow Aboriginal peoples ‘to blow off steam’ before the Crown proceeds to do what it always intended to do,” said the court.

“The inadequacies—more than just a handful and more than mere imperfections—left entire subjects of central interest to the affected First Nations, sometimes subjects affecting their subsistence and well-being, entirely ignored.”

The judges found consultations were especially lacking during the phase that followed the report from the Joint Review Panel—at that time, the Harper government was expected to consult on any concerns that fell outside the JRP mandate.

“Missing was any indication of an intention to amend or supplement the conditions imposed by the Joint Review Panel, to correct any errors or omissions in its Report, or to provide meaningful feedback in reports to the material concerns raised,” said the court.

“Missing was someone from Canada’s side empowered to do more than take notes, someone able to respond meaningfully at some point.”

While the judges did consider a previous court ruling involving the Haida Nation that set a higher bar for consulting First Nations with the strongest case for aboriginal title, they did not agree that the Haida Nation’s many co-management agreements with Canada and B.C. affect that duty.

The court said the current federal government could return the project back to the National Energy Board for more review, or to directly renew consultations with the Haida and other First Nations.

Either would require the new Liberal government to re-approve Northern Gateway.

In a statement, Natural Resources Minister Jim Carr said the government is reviewing the decision, adding that it wants to build a nation-to-nation relationship with indigenous peoples and restore public confidence in environmental reviews.

During the election campaign last fall, Justin Trudeau said if he were elected prime minister, the project would not happen.

Trudeau has since called on Transport Minister Marc Garneau to formalize an oil tanker ban along B.C.’s north coast.

An existing, non-binding moratorium that passed the House of Commons in 2010 excludes oil tankers from Dixon Entrance, Hecate Strait and Queen Charlotte Sound.

John Carruthers, president of the Northern Gateway project, said after the ruling that he will discuss next steps with the  Aboriginal Equity Partners, shipping companies, and other partners that jointly back Northern Gateway.

“The Aboriginal Equity Partners and our commercial project proponents are fully committed to building this critical Canadian infrastructure project while at the same time protecting the environment and the traditional way of life of First Nations and Métis peoples and communities along the project route,” he said in a statement.

Local Skeena-Bulkley Valley MP Nathan Cullen said last Thursday that the ruling shows Canada’s environmental review process is deeply flawed, and need fixing.

The NDP MP and environment critic also said it should encourage the Liberals to move ahead with the north coast tanker ban.

“I think if they were looking for a reason to finally bring it it, this would be it,” he said.

Asked about the future of the Northern Gateway project, Cullen called the ruling a “near-fatal” blow.

“Some have mused that the project is outright dead—I’m not sure that’s true,” he said. “It seems to be the project that never dies.”

The decision rests with Trudeau and his cabinet, Cullen added, noting that he would be very surprised if the prime minister chose to restart consultations on Northern Gateway or appeal last week’s ruling.

“Not for the life of me would I understand why he would do that, particularly after so many commitments on new respect for First Nations and the climate-change concerns he was just speaking about with President Obama yesterday.”.


Just Posted

Photos: Ts’aahl wins super-close Clan Tournament

Three games finished in overtime. In the semi-final, the defending Clan Tournament… Continue reading

New year, same tips from B.C.’s forestry watchdog

Pointing to Haida Gwaii, Forest Practices Board says district managers need more enforcement powers

Fat Tire Girls

Tough north-island duo braves river crossings and storm winds on cycling trek from Tlell to Tow Hill

Time is right for War of the Blink

New Haida manga by Michael Nicoll Yahgulanaas tells a war story that ends in the blink of an eye

Masset Magic: A Christmas Classic to remember

By Jana McLeod Here I am, a full hour before the column… Continue reading

VIDEO: Orcas put on a show near Hornby Island

Louis Jobodin shares photos and video of his experience

How an immigrant to Canada helped Donald Trump prove his mental health

Test that cleared Trump was developed by doctor associated with McGill and Sherbrooke universities

Premier touches on multiple topics ahead of Asia trade trip

Housing and childcare are expected to be the focus of the BC NDP’s first budget in February.

Premier offers condolences to family of boy, 15, killed in Vancouver crossfire

John Horgan: ‘No stone is to be left unturned until we find the perpetrator of this heinous crime’

VIDEO: Explorers uncover Canada’s deepest cave in Fernie

The cave, named Bisaro Anima, was confirmed to have broken the record on New Year’s Day

Players sought for National Aboriginal Hockey Championships

ISPARC calls for bantam/midget players to register for selection camp in Kamloops

New funding opens for industry innovation

Northern Development Initiative Trust opened new funds, focused on areas impacted by the pine beetle

Vernon to host largest Special Olympics B.C. Winter Games in 2019

Games to be held Feb. 21-23, with more than 800 athletes expected to take part

Ex-BC Liberal staffer focused on ‘favourable’ ethnic communities in scandal: lawyer

Former communications director Brian Bonney’s sentencing hearing for breach of trust is underway

Most Read