Islands high schools near bottom of provincial ranking

  • Mar. 11, 2003 1:00 p.m.

Islands’ secondary schools rank near the bottom of this year’s Fraser Institute secondary school report card, and the overall rating at both schools has declined in the last five years.
Queen Charlotte Secondary scored fourteenth from the bottom and George M. Dawson Secondary scored second from the bottom.
The islands’ secondary schools are not alone. Overall, northern schools along Hwy 16 and the Alaska Highway did badly, with all northern communities except Houston scoring in the bottom half of the list.
The Fraser Institute annually rates the overall academic performance of 279 BC public and private schools using eight indicators including graduation rate and average provincial grade 12 examination marks.
School District Superintendent Mike Woods questions the very narrow focus of the Fraser Institute’s criteria for ranking schools.
“We have a few problems with the Fraser Institute ranking. We don’t think they provide an accurate assessment of how schools are doing or how student are learning,” says Mr. Woods.
“It’s a problem for us because most of the criteria for their ranking is from exam scores and graduation rates and we think that for small schools with small student populations it’s not very accurate because a few student can skew the results,” says Mr. Woods. Still, he says, “we honestly think there is room for improvement for the students in our district.”
The School District has an accountability contract, a copy of which is available at the, that outlines those areas the district has targeted for improvement: literacy, social responsibility and numeracy. “We set up specific performance targets and next September/October we will analyse the data we’ve collected,” says Mr. Woods. Some of the criteria used to measure improvement will be the foundation skills assessment, grade promotion, literacy scores and provincial exam scores.
Parents are concerned about exam scores and graduation rates, says Mr. Woods, but they are equally concerned about things the Fraser Institute doesn’t measure such as success in Haida language and studies, art, sports and leadership opportunities. Mr. Woods says all the people in the school district – teachers, teachers’ aides, and principals – are available to provide parents and students with a broad assessment of student achievement and school performance, says Mr. Woods.
Duncan White of the district teacher’s association thinks the Fraser Institute focuses too narrowly on measurable data. “They have no interest in anything they can’t measure,” he says.
“The problem with the Fraser Institute report is that it focuses on some limited data – that we certainly can’t ignore-but it uses it to come up with statistics that may or may not have meaning” says Mr. White.
“I don’t think we should be burying our heads in the sand about this, but they don’t include participation numbers,” says Mr. White. “For instance, in Queen Charlotte Secondary, we encourage students to try things that they are interested in even if they may not do well. We don’t restrict them. Many schools in the province restrict students’ entry into more academic courses like History 12 or Algebra 12, which tends to give them higher results. My personal opinion is that streaming for the school’s PR would be wrong, but it may be sometimes appropriate for the students overall educational benefit.”
Mr. White says there are important things the Fraser Institute report card does not measure. For instance, he suggests that another way of thinking about student success would be to measure how well students are doing a few years after graduation.
“Are they leading productive, satisfying lives? If the school system is really having an effect on students lives that would seem to be an important measurement,” says Mr. White.
“If our schools are indeed in need of more support then our government’s removal of funds from isolated rural school districts certainly won’t help alleviate problems or improve things” says Mr. White.

Just Posted

New ultrasound means less travel for medical services

Ultrasound equipment from Prince Rupert Hospital will help restore islands services

Fishing Haida Gwaii: A salmon fisheries collapse is a terrifying thought

By Darrell Oike Haawa for all the fish caught this week. Spring… Continue reading

Haida Gwaii wrestlers make history at B.C. tournament

It was the first time a wrestling team from Haida Gwaii has ever competed in the B.C.-wide tournament

Tribesmen defeat Haida 77-61 in semi-final matchup at 2018 Junior All Native Basketball Tournament

Prince Rupert Tribesmen advance to finals to face Gitmidiik Storm

Vancouver Aquarium’s resident octopus released into ocean

Staff let the Giant Pacific octopus go into the waters near Bowen Island so she can reproduce

How to keep local news visible in your Facebook feed

Facebook has changed the news feed to emphasize personal connections. You might see less news.

BCHL Today: Prince George avoids elimination with game five win

BCHL Today is a (near) daily look at what’s going on around the league and the junior A world.

Suspect arrested and charged for assault on autistic man

Parmvir Chahil has strong B.C. ties; two others charged with accessory after the fact

Uber self-driving crash video calls safety, rules into question

Experts say footage shows that vehicle’s sensors should have spotted pedestrian, initiated braking

Greens’ Elizabeth May, NDP’s Kennedy Stewart join B.C. anti-pipeline protest

The two politicians could be arrested for violating a court injunction

B.C. man shot by police in 2017 pleads guilty to string of offences

Kaymen Winter gets two years, opts for trial on two charges related to Salmon Arm car wash shooting

Are you going to turn off the lights for Earth Hour?

BC Hydro report says fewer people in the province are taking part, but feel it’s still important

Marijuana edibles won’t be regulated in 2018

Health Canada says edible regulation is still more than a year away

Most Read