Land use plan contentious

  • Jun. 13, 2007 2:00 p.m.

Finalizing the Land Use Plan is essential, according to Council of Haida Nation vice-president Arnie Bellis.
“There are management plans out there through tenures and practice,” Mr. Bellis said, “And these have had no input from the community.”
He’s referring to historic logging practices and more recently, successful attempts by logging companies to apply for permits and log in areas that would have been protected under the Haida Land Use Vision, the basis of the CHN’s position at the land use planning table.
Mr. Bellis says the land use plan has been a long time coming. It was first proposed as necessary during the Islands Community Stability Initiative of the 1990s. Then in 2003, a community planning forum was formed and work co-managed by the province and the Haida began on the plan.
Mr. Bellis says the draft agreement initialled by the CHN and the province and made public at the end of May was the culmination of a long negotiating process.
“We initialled it, so there is a degree of satisfaction. Is one party absolutely happy? Let’s say we found a place where we could move forward,” he said.
The most visible change in this version of the land use plan is the addition of new protected areas.
John Broadhead of the Gowgaia Institute, an island-based sustainability think-tank, explains that the west coast corridor, as well as new protected areas on the east coast of Louise Island, Reef Island, and Cumshewa-Gray Bay, were add-ons to make up for the cutting that had gone on in the last year in proposed protected areas.
The plan as initialled includes 225,000 ha in proposed protected areas and another 37,700 ha in special value areas. These include culturally modified trees, monumental cedar, goshawk, marbled murrelet and other wilderness and biodiversity-valued areas. The management objectives for these are yet to be determined.
Mr. Broadhead says the Ecosystem Based Management objectives in the document are also new and follow the template of those used on the north and central coast. These objectives were a compromise and lower the bar from what was recommended at the Land Use Planning table, he said. The EBM objectives cover things like 100 percent retention of yew trees on cut blocks and a requirement to leave two tree-length buffer zones on streams that are known to be high-value salmon habitat.
But Mr. Broadhead points out that unless the document is signed and made into law soon, business as usual can continue. Companies can take two years grace to adjust their forestry plans and use other loopholes to get around some of the plan’s requirements.
Meanwhile, logging companies like Husby Forest Products (see page 1) and Teal Jones say they will not survive under the new LUP.
Bryan Fraser, operations forester at Teal Jones in Sandspit, says the new allowable annual cut could conceivably drop his cut below 100,000 m3, eliminating the economic viability of his operation. He is also concerned about the “detailed strategic planning” still to be completed after the LUP is approved by Cabinet.
“The devil will definitely be in the details and these details, or the rules for these details, haven’t been determined at this time,” he said.
But Arnie Bellis says protected areas may still shift after further analysis. The government and the CHN are now in the process of studying the impact of ecosystem management objectives on the timber supply. The document outlines an 800,000 m3 per year timber harvest.
As well, a 120,000 m3 Haida tenure is still on the table, as are the aspirations for tenure from the communities, he says.
Mr. Bellis says socio-economic issues are a key part of this document. He notes that more work needs to be done on the community viability report.
Logging is at the tail-end of a resource curve on-island, Mr. Broadhead says, and there is not a lot of old-growth left. The province is already in the position of adjusting stumpage rates to tenure holders, especially the larger ones, in order to help them access whatever is left. He says the district stumpage average was $5.81 for 2006, one of the lowest since the 1980s. Some, like those small businesses in the BC Timber Sales program, are paying up to $40 per m3, while Husby pays an average of $0.43 per m3.
The Land Use Plan will “provide opportunity for the community to take stock and come up with a plan that provides hope for a sustainable future,” he says.
“Or we could finish off the curve and not have any old growth to work with at all.”

Just Posted

Masset fishing derby proves to be a catch

All ages participated in the competition to bring in the top salmon and halibut hauls

Yarn Bombing mastermind is back in town

Big Canada Day longweekend in the works

Maritime Museum project receives legacy grant

A special project of the Dixon Entrance Maritime Museum Society has been… Continue reading

Richardson Ranch celebrating 100 years of family and ranching in Haida Gwaii

Tlell Polled Hereford’s continue to win awards while the ranch becomes a popular spot for visitors

Sustainble economy flourishing in Haida Gwaii and Great Bear Rainforest thanks to First Nations investments

From 2008-2018, funding initiatives led to more than $286 million in new investments

VIDEO: Trans Mountain expansion project gets green light, again

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau announced the decision in Ottawa on Tuesday afternoon

MPs hear retired B.C. nurse’s petition to change compensation for fatal medical errors

Teri McGrath wants provinces to implement no-fault system for medical errors

Horgan says he’ll still defend B.C. coast after second Trans Mountain approval

Meanwhile, one B.C. First Nation has announced plans for a legal challenge

Demonstrators on either side of Trans Mountain debate clash in Vancouver

Crowd heard from member of Indigenous-led coalition that hopes to buy 51% of expansion project

Grieving B.C. mom hopes Facebook message leads to new investigation into son’s Surrey homicide

Criminal Justice Branch didn’t lay charges, concluding no substantial likelihood of murder or manslaughter conviction

B.C.’s measles vaccination program gains traction in May

More than 15,000 doses of the MMR vaccine has been administered across the province

B.C. farmers concerned Agricultural Land Reserve changes choking their livelihood

Dozens voice concerns at special meeting hosted on Vancouver Island

UPDATE: Two-year-old involved in Chilliwack pool drowning has died

Toddler was reported to not be breathing as air ambulance called out Thursday afternoon

Family frustrated Terrace dad with advanced cancer must wait weeks for treatment

‘We can see his health declining every day,’ daughter says

Most Read